Restoring Your Smile, Protecting Your Health.

Premise

The word “cavity” is one no patient wants to hear, but the reality is that most Canadians will need a dental filling at some point in their lives. In the past, the choices were simple. Today, modern dentistry offers a sophisticated array of materials, each with a unique profile of strength, aesthetics, cost, and longevity. The “best” filling is no longer a one-size-fits-all solution; it is a personalized choice based on your specific clinical needs, aesthetic goals, and long-term health priorities.

Introduction

Hearing your dentist say, “We’ve found a small cavity,” used to be followed by a simple discussion about “silver” or “white” fillings. But the field of restorative dentistry has evolved dramatically. We now have materials that can bond directly to your tooth, release fluoride to prevent future decay, or be custom-milled by a computer to match your natural enamel perfectly.

For Canadians, who are often health-conscious and aesthetically aware, understanding these options is crucial. A filling in a front, visible tooth has very different requirements than one in a large, hard-working molar. Health Canada has extensively reviewed materials like amalgam and deemed them safe, yet patient preference continues to shift towards metal-free, tooth-coloured options.

This guide is designed to demystify the five modern dental filling types available to you. We will break down the distinct advantages and disadvantages of each, moving beyond the simple “pros and cons” to give you the detailed information you need. Our goal is to empower you to have a confident, informed conversation with your dentist about which material is the right choice for your smile.

1. The Pros of Amalgam (Silver) Fillings

Amalgam fillings are the “classic” silver-coloured fillings that have been a dental staple for over 150 years. Composed of a stable alloy of mercury, silver, tin, and copper, their primary advantages are strength and cost-effectiveness. When it comes to restoring large cavities in back molars, which endure immense chewing forces, amalgam is a workhorse. Its durability is time-tested, and it remains one of the most reliable and affordable materials in dentistry.

• Exceptional Durability: Amalgam fillings are incredibly tough and resistant to wear.They are an excellent choice for large cavities in the back of the mouth (molars).
• Proven Longevity: With proper care, a well-placed amalgam filling can easily last 10 to 15 years, and often much longer.
• Cost-Effective: This is generally the most affordable filling material, making it accessible to a wide range of patients and often fully covered by basic insurance plans.
• Efficient Placement: Amalgam fillings can typically be placed in a single, relatively quick appointment.
• Technique Tolerance: The placement process is less sensitive to the presence of moisture (like saliva) compared to composite resin, which can lead to a more predictable long-term result in difficult-to-isolate areas.
• Bacteriostatic Properties: The metals in the alloy, particularly silver, can have a mild “bacteriostatic” effect, meaning they can help inhibit the growth of new bacteria at the filling’s margins.
• Time-Tested Safety: Despite concerns over its mercury content, major health bodies, including Health Canada and the Canadian Dental Association (CDA), have repeatedly reviewed the scientific evidence and consider dental amalgam a safe, stable, and effective restorative material for adults and children over six.

2. The Cons of Amalgam (Silver) Fillings

The most significant and obvious drawback of amalgam is its appearance. The metallic, silver-to-black colour stands in sharp contrast to the natural tooth, making it a poor choice for any visible part of the smile. Beyond aesthetics, amalgam requires a more “aggressive” preparation, meaning more of the healthy tooth structure must be removed to create a “mechanical lock” that holds the filling in place, as it does not bond to the tooth.

• Poor Aesthetics: The metallic colour is highly visible and does not blend with the natural tooth, which is the primary reason patients seek alternatives.
• Less Conservative Preparation: Amalgam doesn’t bond to the tooth. To stay in place, the dentist must create an undercut “box” shape, which often requires the removal of healthy, sound tooth structure beyond just the decay.
• Thermal Conductivity: As a metal, amalgam conducts hot and cold temperatures.This can lead to a brief, sharp sensitivity when consuming hot or cold foods, especially in the first few weeks after placement.
• Potential for Tooth Fractures: Metal expands and contracts with temperature changes at a different rate than the natural tooth. This can, over many years, put stress on the tooth and potentially lead to “microfractures” or cracks.
• Discolouration of Tooth: Over time, a faint greyish or blueish tinge from the amalgam can leach into the surrounding enamel and dentin, discolouring the tooth from the inside out.
• Mercury Content Concerns: Although the mercury is in a stable, bound alloy, its very presence is a concern for some patients.
• Environmental Impact: The disposal of mercury from dental offices is an environmental concern, and many Canadian provinces have implemented strict protocols for its capture and disposal.

3. The Pros of Composite Resin (Tooth-Coloured) Fillings

Composite resin is the modern standard for aesthetic fillings.This is the “white filling” that most patients now request. It’s a tooth-coloured mixture of plastic resin and fine glass particles that can be precisely matched to the shade of your natural teeth.Its greatest advantage is its ability to be chemically bonded directly to the tooth, which not only looks natural but also supports the remaining tooth structure.

• Superior Aesthetics: The material comes in a wide spectrum of shades and opacities, allowing the dentist to create a repair that is virtually invisible.
• Conservative Tooth Preparation: Because composite resin is bonded to the tooth, the dentist only needs to remove the decayed portion. This “minimally invasive” approach preserves as much healthy tooth structure as possible.
• Bonding and Support: The bonding process itself can help to strengthen and reinforce the remaining tooth, “gluing” it together and making it more resistant to fracture.
• Versatility: Composite is an all-purpose material. It can be used to fill small-to-mid-sized cavities in both front and back teeth, and it’s also used for cosmetic “bonding” to fix chips, close gaps, or change a tooth’s shape.
• Good Insulator: Unlike amalgam, composite does not conduct hot and cold temperatures well, resulting in less post-operative thermal sensitivity.
• Mercury-Free: This is a major selling point for patients who have concerns about mercury.
• Repairable: If a small part of a composite filling chips or wears, it can often be repaired by adding new composite, whereas a damaged amalgam filling usually needs to be completely replaced.
• Immediate Hardening: The resin is hardened instantly with a high-intensity blue light, meaning you can chew on it as soon as the anaesthetic wears off.

4. The Cons of Composite Resin (Tooth-Coloured) Fillings

While composite resin is aesthetically superior, it has trade-offs. It is not as strong or durable as amalgam, and it may not be the best choice for very large cavities on back molars that handle heavy chewing. The placement process is also highly “technique-sensitive,” meaning it requires a perfectly dry and clean environment to achieve a strong bond. Lastly, it’s a porous material and can stain over time, just like natural teeth.

• Less Durable: Composite fillings typically last 5 to 10 years, which is less than the lifespan of amalgam or gold. They can wear down more quickly on heavy chewing surfaces.
• Susceptible to Staining: Over time, composite can absorb stains from coffee, tea, red wine, curry, and tobacco, leading to discolouration.
• Higher Cost: Composite fillings are more expensive than amalgam fillings.
• Longer Placement Time: The process is more meticulous. The filling must be placed in small, incremental layers, with each layer being “cured” with the blue light, which takes more time.
• Technique-Sensitive: The success of the filling depends heavily on maintaining a completely dry field. Any contamination from saliva during the bonding process can lead to a weaker bond and premature failure.
• Potential for Shrinkage: As the composite resin hardens (cures), it can shrink very slightly. This “polymerization shrinkage” can potentially create microscopic gaps between the filling and the tooth, leading to sensitivity or recurrent decay.
• Not Ideal for All Situations: May not be recommended for very large restorations, in patients who clench or grind heavily (bruxism), or for fillings that extend far below the gumline where moisture control is impossible.

5. The Pros of Ceramic (Porcelain) Fillings

Ceramic fillings, also known as porcelain inlays or onlays, represent the premium tier of aesthetic restorations. These are not “filled” directly into the tooth in one visit. Instead, an impression or digital scan of the prepared tooth is taken and sent to a dental lab (or milled in-office with a CEREC machine) where a custom piece of high-strength ceramic is fabricated. It is then bonded into the tooth at a second appointment.

• Unmatched Aesthetics: Porcelain has a translucency and shine that perfectly mimics natural tooth enamel. It is the most beautiful and natural-looking restoration available.
• Excellent Stain Resistance: Unlike composite, ceramic is a non-porous material and is highly resistant to staining. It will remain a stable, bright colour for its entire lifespan.
• Superior Durability: Modern dental ceramics are incredibly strong and wear-resistant.They are much more durable than composite resin and can last 15 years or more.
• Biocompatibility: Porcelain is very “kind” to the gum tissues and is highly biocompatible, with no risk of metal allergies.
• Ideal for Larger Cavities: Inlays (which fill the area between the cusps) and onlays (which cover one or more cusps) are perfect for restoring larger cavities that are too big for a composite filling but not large enough to require a full crown.
• Protects Tooth Structure: Like composite, they are bonded to the tooth, which helps to reinforce it.
• Mercury-Free and Metal-Free: A fully ceramic option for patients seeking a holistic approach.

6. The Cons of Ceramic (Porcelain) Fillings

The high-end benefits of ceramic restorations come with two primary drawbacks: significant cost and the need for multiple appointments. They are also a harder material than natural enamel, which can have an impact on the teeth that bite against them.

• High Cost: Ceramic restorations are one of the most expensive filling options, often costing as much as a gold filling or a full dental crown.
• Multiple Appointments: Traditional lab-fabricated ceramic inlays/onlays require at least two dental visits: one for preparation and impressions, and a second for bonding the final piece.
• Brittleness: While very hard, ceramic can also be brittle.Under a sharp, direct, or excessive biting force (like biting an olive pit), it can fracture.
• Wear on Opposing Teeth: Because porcelain is harder than natural tooth enamel, it can cause accelerated wear on the opposing tooth it bites against.
• Lab Fabrication: The quality of the final restoration is highly dependent on the skill of both the dentist and the dental laboratory technician who fabricates it.
• Not Repairable: If a ceramic inlay chips or breaks, it cannot be patched or repaired. The entire restoration must be replaced.
• Complex Bonding: The cementation process is, like composite, very technique-sensitive and requires a perfectly isolated environment.

7. The Pros of Glass Ionomer Fillings

Glass ionomer is a unique filling material made of acrylic and a specific type of glass. Its most significant and defining characteristic is its ability to release fluoride into the surrounding tooth structure. This special property makes it an invaluable tool for preventing new decay from forming, especially for patients at high risk for cavities.

• Fluoride Release: This is its key benefit. Glass ionomer actively leaches fluoride over time, which helps to remineralize the adjacent tooth enamel and prevent “recurrent decay” around the filling.
• Ideal for High-Risk Patients: This makes it the material of choice for patients with dry mouth (xerostomia), extensive root decay, or difficulty with oral hygiene.
• Common Pediatric Use: It is very commonly used to fill “baby teeth” (primary teeth) in children, as the fluoride helps protect the underlying permanent tooth.
• Excellent for Non-Chewing Surfaces: It is the perfect material for filling small cavities on the “necks” of the teeth (root surfaces) or near the gumline, where decay is common and chewing forces are low.
• Chemical Bond to Tooth: Glass ionomer chemically bonds to both the enamel and the dentin of the tooth, which creates a good seal.
• Good Biocompatibility: It is very gentle on the tooth’s nerve (pulp).
• Can Be Used as a “Liner”: Dentists sometimes place a thin layer of glass ionomer under a different type of filling (like composite) to get the benefit of its fluoride release and seal.

8. The Cons of Glass Ionomer Fillings

The trade-off for glass ionomer’s fluoride-releasing benefit is its profound lack of strength. It is the weakest and most brittle of all filling materials and simply cannot withstand the heavy forces of chewing on permanent adult teeth. Its aesthetics are also quite poor.

• Low Strength and Durability: This is its main drawback. It is very prone to fracture and wears down quickly.
• Not for Chewing Surfaces: It should never be used on the biting surfaces of permanent molars or premolars.
• Poor Aesthetics: The material is opaque and does not match the natural translucency of teeth. It also comes in a very limited range of shades, making it look “flat” and noticeable.
• Water Sensitivity: During the setting process, it is very sensitive to water contamination, which can weaken the material.
• Limited Lifespan: These fillings are not considered permanent solutions for adult biting surfaces and may need to be replaced more frequently.
• Hybrid Versions: To combat the weakness, “resin-modified glass ionomers” (RMGIs) were created.These are stronger and look better but are still a compromise and not as strong as composite.
• Specific Use Only: Its application is highly specialized and limited to the situations described in the “Pros” section.

9. The Pros of Cast Gold Fillings

Cast gold (or gold alloy) inlays and onlays are the “gold standard” of dental restorations, and for good reason. While their popularity has waned due to cost and aesthetics, no other material can match their longevity. Fabricated in a lab like ceramic, a gold filling is incredibly durable, non-corrosive, and exceptionally gentle on the opposing teeth.

• Unmatched Durability: Gold is the strongest and most long-lasting material. A well-done gold inlay can easily last 20, 30, or even 40+ years—often a lifetime.
• Exceptional Strength: It can withstand any chewing or grinding force without cracking, chipping, or wearing down.
• Kind to Opposing Teeth: Gold wears at a rate almost identical to natural tooth enamel, meaning it will not cause premature wear on the teeth it bites against (a major advantage over ceramic).
• Excellent Biocompatibility: Gold is extremely well-tolerated by the body and gum tissues. Allergic reactions are exceptionally rare.
• Does Not Corrode: Gold will not tarnish or corrode in the moist environment of the mouth.
• Precision Fit: The lab-casting process allows for an incredibly precise and accurate fit, which creates a very strong seal against bacteria.
• Proven Track Record: It has a long history of successful use in dentistry, with decades of clinical data to back it up.

10. The Cons of Cast Gold Fillings

The downsides of gold are few but significant. The most obvious is the highly visible, metallic appearance, which most Canadian patients are no longer willing to accept, especially in a visible area. The second major hurdle is the price tag.

• Very High Cost: Gold is, by a significant margin, the most expensive restorative material. The cost is high due to the price of the precious metal itself and the highly skilled lab work required.
• Poor Aesthetics: The bright yellow, metallic appearance is a non-starter for most people. It is the least natural-looking option.
• Multiple Appointments: Like ceramic, gold restorations require at least two dental visits for preparation, impressions, and final cementation.
• Thermal Conductivity: Like amalgam, gold is a metal and will conduct hot and cold, which can lead to temporary sensitivity.
• Galvanic Shock: A very rare but possible side-effect. If a new gold filling is placed directly adjacent to or touching an old amalgam filling, it can create a tiny electrical current (like a battery) that causes a small, sharp “jolt.” This is temporary but unpleasant.
• Complex Procedure: Placing a gold inlay or onlay requires a high degree of precision and skill from the dentist.

Conclusion

Modern dentistry has truly personalized the process of restoring a tooth. As we’ve seen, there is no single “best” filling. The “best” choice for you will always be a careful balance of factors:

• Location and Size: Is the cavity on a visible front tooth or a hard-working back molar?
• Aesthetics: How important is it that the filling is invisible?
• Durability: Are you a heavy clencher or grinder?
• Cost: What does your budget or insurance plan allow for?
• Future Health: Are you at high risk for new cavities?

A composite filling might be perfect for a small cavity on your premolar, while a large, deep cavity on a molar might be better served by a strong amalgam filling or a durable ceramic onlay. The most important step is to have an open, transparent conversation with your dentist. By understanding your options, you can work together to select the material that will restore your tooth to full health, function, and beauty for years to come.

Your Healthiest Smile is a Choice

The options can seem complex, but you don’t have to make the decision alone. At Nebo Dental Centre, our team is dedicated to guiding you through every choice with clear, honest advice tailored to your specific needs. Let’s find the perfect solution for your smile.

Name: Nebo Dental Centre
Address: 260 Nebo Road, Hamilton, ON L8W 3K5
Phone: 905.381.9802
Email: [email protected]
Website: https://nebodentalcentre.com/

Unlock Your Best Smile: A Hamilton Resident’s Guide to Dazzling Cosmetic Dental Transformations